The first hours after a truck crash feel chaotic. Sirens, flashing lights, phones buzzing with questions you’re not ready to answer. While medical care comes first, the evidence available in that window determines how strong your case can be weeks or months later. I’ve handled enough truck cases in Garland and across Dallas County to know the difference between a close call and a clean win often comes down to how quickly and precisely we lock down proof.
Truck cases don’t move like car wrecks. There’s a federal overlay, deep-pocketed insurers, corporate risk teams, and data trails that fade if you don’t act. A seasoned Garland Truck Accident Lawyer knows where those trails run and how to preserve them. Below I’ll explain the categories of evidence that matter most, how to secure them, and where people unintentionally weaken their claims. You’ll see why timing and technical details carry more weight than slogans about “fighting for you.”
Why truck crashes are a different animal
A fully loaded 18-wheeler can weigh up to 80,000 pounds. That mass amplifies everything: stopping distance, impact forces, and the range of possible failures. Commercial Thompson Law Thompson Law drivers operate under the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations (FMCSRs), and carriers maintain records you’ll never find in a standard fender-bender. Think electronic logging devices, driver qualification files, maintenance logs, dispatch notes, telematics, and sometimes forward- and driver-facing cameras. Much of it cycles out by policy or regulation if no one demands preservation.
In Texas, fault determinations are comparative. If the defense nudges even 10–20 percent of the blame onto you, it can shave real money off your recovery. That’s why evidence quality matters as much as evidence quantity. A Garland Injury Lawyer who understands local roads, common loading zones, and familiar delivery routes will know where to look and who to chase.
Scene-level evidence: small details, big leverage
I tell clients this: once you’re medically stable, document the scene like you’ll never get back there, because you probably won’t. Police do their job, but they aren’t building your civil case.
Start with position and perspective. Photos from your eye level show what you could see, where sightlines break, and how sunlight or shadows fell. Step back for wider angles that capture lane markings, debris fields, and skid or yaw marks. If you can safely do it, video a slow walk-around with narration. Mention smells of hot brakes, diesel, leaking fluids, or burnt rubber. These details help accident reconstructionists later, especially when you can’t return to a cleared roadway.
Eyewitnesses help when they’re actually identified. A first name and “blue shirt” won’t do it. Press for a phone number and email. If they’re reluctant, ask to text them right then so the thread is saved. I’ve salvaged multiple cases because a bystander captured a few seconds of video before the scene changed. That clip might show the truck’s turn signal—or lack of one—or a trailer door swinging open from a bad latch.
Finally, don’t overlook the environment. Was construction rerouting traffic on Buckingham Road? Were traffic signals blinking at Forest Lane after a storm? Snap the signage, cones, or temporary detours. A Garland Accident Lawyer who knows how those intersections typically flow can match your images to a credible narrative.
The police report: useful, not gospel
The Texas Peace Officer’s Crash Report is a starting point, not a finish line. Many officers work quickly under stress. I’ve seen wrong vehicle positions, mixed-up VINs, and assumptions about speed without supporting measurements. If you’re conscious at the scene, give a simple, factual statement: where you were, what you saw, what you did to avoid impact. Avoid speculating about speed or fault. If the officer issues a citation to the truck driver, that helps, but it isn’t conclusive in civil court.
Once the report is ready, review it with your lawyer. We cross-check diagrams against photos, time of day against sun angle, and listed witnesses against our own outreach. If something is clearly mistaken, we can sometimes submit a correction or supplement.
Medical records that tell the whole story
Trauma speaks most clearly on day one, but soft-tissue injuries and concussions unfold over days or weeks. Emergency departments document acute findings, not the entire arc of your recovery. Create a consistent medical timeline that connects your symptoms to the crash without gaps the defense can exploit.
Be candid with providers about prior injuries, but precise. “I had a back strain five years ago that resolved with therapy” lands differently than “yeah, I’ve always had back problems.” Charting matters. If you felt tingling in your right hand at the scene, say so, even if it seems minor. In one Garland case, that detail justified a cervical MRI that later found a herniation, shifting a low offer into six figures.
Save everything: discharge summaries, imaging reports, referral notes, prescriptions, and physical therapy logs. Juries respond to clear progressions: problem identified, treatment recommended, compliance shown, results documented. A Garland Personal Injury Lawyer will build that sequence so an adjuster sees the cost of ignoring it.
Vehicles don’t lie: downloads and inspections
Physical evidence from the vehicles often decides liability. Modern commercial tractors and some trailers carry electronic control modules (ECMs) and telematics capable of logging speed, throttle, brake application, RPM, fault codes, and sometimes hard-braking events. Many fleets use systems like Omnitracs, Samsara, or Geotab that track speed against posted limits, lane departures, and hours-of-service compliance.
This is where a preservation letter earns its keep. Sent promptly, it instructs the carrier and its insurer to retain:
- All electronic data from the tractor and trailer, including ECM, telematics, and camera footage.
If we delay, footage can be overwritten in as little as 24 to 72 hours, and some ECMs lose high-resolution data after a handful of ignition cycles. I once recovered driver-facing video that captured a 3-second glance down at a phone just before impact. Without a rapid letter, that clip would have been auto-deleted by the weekend.
An independent inspection matters just as much. A defense shop will frame findings in their favor. We use a qualified reconstructionist to photograph undercarriage components, measure brake stroke, inspect ABS indicators, and map crush patterns. Even modest underride marks can reveal closing speeds, while tire scuffing can show evasive maneuvers or jackknife dynamics. On a Garland case involving LBJ Freeway traffic, we matched a trailer’s tire scrape to a sudden lane change by the truck, not the car, shifting fault back where it belonged.
The driver’s paper trail: qualifications and compliance
Under the FMCSRs, carriers must maintain a Driver Qualification File (DQF). It includes the driver’s application, motor vehicle records, road test or CDL, prior employer checks, medical exam certs, and sometimes training documents. A Garland Truck Accident Lawyer will pursue this file early. Red flags include recent log violations, prior crashes, out-of-service orders, or a medical certification that should have sidelined the driver.
Hours-of-service (HOS) logs used to be on paper; now they’re typically electronic via ELDs. We compare HOS logs to delivery schedules, fuel receipts, toll data, cell phone records, and even weigh station hits. If the log says the driver rested in Terrell but his phone pinged repeatedly near Mesquite at 2 a.m., we’ve got a credibility problem—and potentially a punitive damages argument if fatigue played a role.
Dispatch and route communications also matter. Texts or Qualcomm messages that push aggressive timelines can expose a culture that prioritizes delivery over safety. I’ve seen dispatchers write “make up the time” after a traffic jam. That line has a way of changing negotiation posture.
Cameras everywhere: dash, driver-facing, and beyond
Camera evidence can be a blessing or a brawl. Many fleets run forward-facing cameras that trigger on hard braking or impact. Driver-facing cameras are more sensitive; carriers sometimes restrict access citing privacy or policy. Persist. We request the event video and 10–30 minutes before and after. That buffer shows whether the driver was distracted earlier or battling fatigue.
Intersection and business cameras fill gaps. In Garland, several gas stations and fast-casual restaurants keep rolling footage for a week or two. If the crash happens near a retail strip, we dispatch an investigator same-day to request copies before they overwrite. City traffic cameras are trickier, and access depends on agency policies, but a polite call within 24 hours often goes farther than a subpoena filed too late.
Your own vehicle may hold data too. Some modern cars store speed and brake applications in an airbag control module. When our download aligns with skid marks and ECM data, it closes the door on defense speculation.
Maintenance records: the quiet backbone of liability
A pristine logbook can be as powerful as an incriminating one. If brakes were out of adjustment or a tire was worn beyond spec, that’s direct negligence. If maintenance looks perfect, but the parts show uneven wear, we look deeper: Did a third-party shop pencil-whip inspections? Did the carrier ignore driver Vehicle Inspection Reports noting vibration or pulling? In one case, daily pre-trip inspections were signed in under a minute, every day, by the same hand. Not plausible. That pattern undermined the defense’s “we maintain our fleet” narrative.
Keep in mind maintenance files may live with a leasing company if the carrier doesn’t own the tractor. A Garland Injury Lawyer who has chased these documents before will know to broaden the net.
Cell phones: the modern smoking gun
The cleanest distraction cases come from call logs and app data. It’s rarely enough to say the driver “may have been on the phone.” We seek records showing an active call, text, or app usage in the minutes before impact. Some carriers forbid handheld use; if the driver broke policy, we’ll find it. Defense will argue hands-free is safe. Jurors tend to disagree when timing aligns with lane drift or delayed braking.
There’s a flip side. Your own phone data can become fair game if the defense claims you were distracted. I prepare clients for this conversation early. If you weren’t using your phone, we say so and stand on it. If you were changing music or using navigation, we tell the truth and explain the context. Honesty resolves more problems than clever evasions.
Weather, lighting, and roadway design
Texas weather whipsaws. A dry road at 5 p.m. can slick over by 6 if a pop-up storm hits. Downloading historical weather data for the exact location and time helps frame expectations for speed and following distance. Sunset angle matters too. On east-west corridors like Miller Road, a low sun can reduce visibility. Professional drivers must adjust for conditions; that’s not just common sense, it’s codified in the FMCSRs.
Road design can share blame. Missing reflectors, faded lane lines, or an obscured stop sign can be part of the narrative. Still, carriers tend to overplay this, claiming “sudden emergency” for conditions they should anticipate. We balance it: acknowledge real hazards but show how a safe driver compensates.
Economic damages: numbers that add up without drama
Lost wages, medical bills, and future care require math that holds up to cross-examination. We gather paycheck stubs, tax returns, and employer verification to show actual loss. For self-employed clients, we use profit-and-loss statements and bank records rather than vague estimates. In one Garland case involving a contractor, itemized invoices told a tighter story than any accountant letter could.
Future care needs a treating physician’s support, not just an expert-for-hire. Physical therapy frequency, injections on a predictable schedule, or a likely surgery in the next 2–3 years form the backbone of a life care plan. When those numbers align with regional costs—what Baylor Scott & White, Medical City, or therapy clinics in Garland actually charge—adjusters stop treating them as wish lists.
Non-economic damages: credibility beats theatrics
Pain, limitations, and the way an injury reshapes a life are real, but they must be shown, not proclaimed. I ask clients to keep a simple recovery journal: what you could do before, what hurts now, how long an activity takes, how often you wake at night. Photos of a half-mowed yard or an unfinished project say more than adjectives. Friends and family can provide statements, but I prefer one or two with specific examples: “She used to carry our toddler upstairs nightly; now we trade off and he cries when she can’t.”
Jurors in Dallas County respond to straight talk. They discount exaggeration, but they respect consistent, documented hardship. Your Garland Accident Lawyer should help you calibrate tone without sanding off the truth.
The spoliation clock: preserving what matters before it vanishes
Evidence disappears on a schedule, sometimes by policy, sometimes by inertia. A formal preservation letter puts the carrier on notice to retain:
- ELD/HOS logs, dispatch communications, and driver-facing and forward-facing video around the event.
Send it fast, send it to the right recipients—the carrier, its insurer, and if known, the outside claims administrator. If they let something vanish after notice, a judge can allow a spoliation instruction that tells the jury to assume the missing evidence would have hurt the defense. You’d be surprised how attitudes change when that possibility hits.
Common missteps that shrink otherwise solid cases
Insurance adjusters thrive on gaps. Don’t give them easy ones. Delayed medical care creates arguments that you weren’t hurt badly or that something else happened in between. Social media becomes a trap; a single smiling photo at a family event without context can be used to suggest a full recovery. I once had to explain a client’s “Back at it!” caption that referred to a desk job, not heavy lifting.
Recorded statements are another minefield. Be polite but brief. If an adjuster asks you to guess speeds or distances, decline. Tell them you’re focusing on treatment and that your Garland Personal Injury Lawyer will follow up. Early estimates about property damage without a complete inspection can lock you into a low replacement value.
How timing shapes strategy
There’s a rhythm to these cases. In the first 30 days, preserve evidence, secure scene and vehicle data, and get medical traction. In the next 60–120 days, build the liability case: downloads, maintenance, DQF, and witnesses. Only after the treatment plan stabilizes do we evaluate settlement posture. If surgery is likely, the defense will often push to settle before the recommendation becomes formal. That may be tempting; it’s usually too soon.
Trials are rare but real. When the defense denies liability despite strong evidence, a jury can be the right audience. Garland jurors are practical. They don’t need theatrics; they need clean timelines, honest witnesses, and technical proof they can trust.
Local knowledge: Garland quirks that matter
High-crash corridors develop patterns. Along South Garland Avenue, midday delivery traffic mixes with local turns into shopping centers. On I-635, tight merges near construction zones create pinch points that reward patience and punish tailgating. I keep a mental map of where cameras tend to sit and which businesses are cooperative with footage requests. That speeds the hunt.
Hospitals and clinics in the area follow their own record cycles. Some can produce radiology discs in a day; others quote two weeks. Knowing which clerk to call can shave days off your timeline. Small edges accumulate.
Why a coordinated team beats a lone ranger
A strong case blends legal judgment with technical specialists. Accident reconstructionists, biomechanical experts when needed, and medical providers who document well. The right expert isn’t always the most famous; it’s the one who explains without condescension. Adjusters can smell a bought opinion. We avoid them. A Garland Truck Accident Lawyer who cultivates a trusted bench will use the lightest possible roster to tell the clearest story.
A practical, short checklist for the first week
- Get medical care and follow the plan; note all symptoms, even minor ones. Photograph vehicles, injuries, the scene, and any road or weather conditions. Collect contact info for witnesses and nearby businesses with cameras. Preserve your own vehicle and do not authorize destructive repairs until advised. Call a lawyer early to send preservation letters and coordinate downloads.
The bottom line: evidence wins quiet battles
Most truck cases don’t end with dramatic courtroom moments. They end with a phone call where the adjuster’s tone changes because the file tells a story they can’t poke holes in. That happens when the right evidence is found, preserved, and arranged with care.
If you were hit by a commercial truck in Garland, focus on your recovery and guard your credibility. Let a Garland Truck Accident Lawyer do the heavy lifting on the technical side: ECM downloads, HOS audits, camera retrievals, and the paper chase that turns doubt into proof. Experienced counsel—whether you call them a Garland Personal Injury Lawyer, a Garland Injury Lawyer, or simply your advocate—knows which details move numbers and which distractions waste time.
Evidence doesn’t care how loud anyone talks. It cares how fast you act, how thoroughly you document, and how well your team understands the terrain. That’s how you shift a case from maybe to yes.
Contact Us
Thompson Law
375 Cedar Sage Dr Suite 285, Garland, TX 75040, USA
Phone: (469) 772-9314